| Year | Hall of Fame Inductee | Old Timers Hall of Fame Inductee |
| 1956 | Jack Towers | |
| 1957 | Joseph A. Ferko | |
| 1958 | James A. Durning | |
| 1959 | Fred J. Kesel | |
| 1960 | Peter A. Broomall | |
| 1961 | Raymond Endriss | |
| 1962 | Robert Runkle, Jr. | |
| 1963 | Raymond Gurt | |
| 1964 | Walter Krop | |
| 1965 | Harry Straub | |
| 1966 | Harry Lawson | |
| 1967 | William Mink Harry Whitman |
|
| 1968 | John Fralinger Dave Anderson |
|
| 1969 | Robert Hall John Hogg |
|
| 1970 | John Baukus Fred Calandra |
|
| 1971 | Adam Quaglia Joseph Bruecks |
|
| 1972 | George Duffy Robert Ziegler |
|
| 1973 | Jim Donaghy Peter Amadie |
|
| 1974 | John Arleth Henry J. Kunzig, Sr. |
|
| 1975 | John E. Mayer Joseph Pisuzko |
|
| 1976 | Edward Venckus Arthur (Link) Gardner |
|
| 1977 | Anthony (Iggy) Geneva Joseph Blass Al Fink |
|
| 1978 | Henry Kunzig, Jr. Herb Smith, Jr. |
David (Pop) Anderson |
| 1979 | Ron Moyer Herman Seflin |
Al Primavera, Sr. |
| 1980 | James Broomall Anthony (Tish) Bordoni |
Sam Hamilton, Jr. |
| 1981 | James M. Driadon John Walsh |
Joseph Riley |
| 1982 | Tom A. Howley Joseph L. Bresset |
James J. King |
| 1983 | Don Keir Bill (Curly) Conners |
Henry Dunaway |
| 1984 | Ray Danielewicz William R. Kurzenberger |
Edward (Rob) Carter |
| 1985 | Joseph Deighan Phil Peschi |
Joe (Bagel) Strine |
| 1986 | Joseph A. Venuto Clifford J. Johnson |
Al Stewart |
| 1987 | Jack Hee Bob Shannon, Jr. |
Carl Jankiewicz |
| 1988 | Al Primavera, Jr. Edward P. Broomall |
Joseph Giardino, Jr. |
| 1989 | Nicholas "Duke" Buonpastore Stan Pojat |
Joseph Jankowski |
| 1990 | Thomas E. King Len Giacobetti, Sr. |
Gene M. Nemeth |
| 1991 | William Speziale David Anderson, Jr. |
Mieckey Mallon |
| 1992 | Frank Anello | Clement C. Rende |
| 1993 | Joseph Brogan | Frank Kohri |
| 1994 | James Fox, Jr. John Millaway |
John Pooler, Sr. |
| 1995 | Mike Rayer | Rich Nottis, Sr. |
| 1996 | James J. Fox, Sr. | |
| 1997 | Joseph Long | |
| 1998 | John G. "Ozzie" Ostrowski Daniel F. Creedon, III |
John "Pop" Pignotti, Sr. |
| 1999 | William Bowen, Sr. William Bowen, Jr. |
Robert "Pop" Shannon |
| 2000 | James "Jimmy" King | Russell "Mr. Fig" Figueroa |
| 2001 | Joseph "Joe T" Trinacria | |
| 2002 | Walter "Duke" Burkhardt John Machalowski Don Morrissey Jim McKnight John R. Pignotti, Jr. Robert W. Quaile, Sr. |
Charles N. Muraresku, Sr. |
| 2003 | Francis J. Foidl, Jr. Harry Hill Tom Loomis James Moran, Jr. J. Kevin O'Brien |
Angelo Carango John Wright, Sr. |
| 2004 | George J. Badey, III Robert J. (Bobby) Cunningham Tom Donahue Charlie Nicholas |
William (Pop) Deissroth James (Pop) McKnight |
| 2005 | Bob Corcoran Thomas Ferry Theodore F. Kudrick John Rasmus, Sr. Charlie Roetz Fran Rothwein, Jr. |
Bob Holtz Jim Murray |
| 2006 | Anthony Celenza Jerry LaRosa, Jr. |
Frank Rothwein |
| 2007 | Joseph King Charles Kochensky |
Harry Brown, Sr. Bob Morrisey |
| 2008 | Mike (Lapp) Lapergola Scott Moyer |
Cy Daly Robert E. "Bob" Dicks Robert H. Finnegan |
| 2009 | Bob Farrell Ray Malach |
Archie White Spence White Sam Hamilton, Sr. |
| 2010 | Hon. Robert (Bob) Brady Joseph Bujnowski Joseph Leso Dennis Quaile |
Al Koenig Donald Reeves |
| 2011 | Jerry Crompton Cheryl Crowe Marty Good Steve Highsmith Jim Jaep Margaret "Peg" Rullo Jim Tatar, Sr. |
|
| 2012 | Jim Browne Jack Dailey John Jordan Ed Lynch John Wernega Bill Garton Warren Rivell Anthony Tenuto |
|
| 2013 | Mark Danielewicz Dan Marakowski Dan Spencer Joe Volkert |
|
| 2014 | Denny Palandro Bob Schuhl Ed Weisser |
|
| 2015 | Peter J. (Pete) Broomall, Sr. Jamie Caldwell Steve Coper Robert A. (Bob) King Leo Volz |
If you have any info such as Corrections or missing information, please feel free to E-mail me!
� 2006 finkmeister@live.com
